We've given Refundee a new look, learn more.
HJ Collection: MHA Appointed as Insolvency Practitioner: What It Means for Investors
Published November 17, 2026On 17 November 2026, HJ Collection investors received a letter from CEO Reece Mennie confirming that Bluewater Capital, the Security Trustee, has appointed an insolvency practitioner on the HJ Collection SPV Companies. The letter names MHA Advisory Ltd (16233746) as the firm appointed by the Security Trustee. In an appointment letter seen by Refundee, it appears that Steven Iles and Andrew Duncan of MHA have been appointed across the SPVs.
Unfortunately, following revelations within the FCA's High Court action against Hunter Jones in September, it felt like this news was inevitable and Refundee has been planning for this. Bank reimbursement schemes are now extremely likely to be the best option for investors and Refundee are already progressing and sending cases.
The HJ Collection case has drawn widespread press attention given the number of investors involved. Refundee was recently featured in The Telegraph, explaining what investors should do next.
Below, we explain what the letter says, who MHA are, what an insolvency process is likely to mean for your loan notes, and the options available if you want to try to get your money back.
In short:
- Reece Mennie, director of all HJ Collection SPVs, asked the Security Trustee to appoint an insolvency practitioner. MHA has been appointed.
- MHA is a large, reputable UK accountancy firm with a licensed restructuring and insolvency team. It will now take control of and manage the SPVs' assets for the benefit of creditors.
- Investors will almost certainly receive no more returns of interest and capital. It is possible that there will be a distribution to investors at the end of the insolvency process, but generally in such cases, at best, a distribution would be partial and a fraction of what is owed.
- The insolvency process is separate from bank reimbursement claims. If you paid from a UK bank account, you may be able to claim through your bank and the Financial Ombudsman Service, but strict time limits can apply. Therefore, you need to act quickly.
HJ Collection and Hunter Jones: a quick recap
HJ Collection is a group of special purpose vehicles (SPVs), HJ Collection Ltd (HJC1) through to HJ Collection 6 Limited (HJC6). Each SPV raised money from investors by issuing loan notes, with the funds described as being used for UK property development projects. Reece Mennie is the sole director of every SPV.
The loan notes were marketed and sold by Osborne Baldwin Limited, which trades as Hunter Jones and Hunter Jones Group. Mr Mennie founded the firm in 2013.
According to the FCA's court filings, as set out in our earlier coverage, the regulator alleges that money from newer loan note investors was used to repay earlier investors rather than fund the advertised projects. It is asking for the SPVs to repay investors or, if they cannot, be placed into liquidation.
These are allegations. The court has not ruled on them, and Hunter Jones and Mr Mennie deny them. Importantly, in its High Court action the FCA also alleged that “This is a Ponzi scheme”.
For the full background, see our HJ Collection / Hunter Jones group action page.
What does the 17 November 2026 letter say?
The letter, sent to all investors in the HJ Collection SPV companies, confirms that Mr Mennie asked the Security Trustee to appoint an insolvency practitioner over the SPVs, and that MHA has been appointed.
The main points are:
- The reason given. Mr Mennie says the FCA's action against Hunter Jones made it impossible for the SPVs to operate normally and left him with no other choice. He describes bringing in an independent insolvency practitioner as the responsible step to protect the companies' assets.
- Position on the FCA case. The letter states that Hunter Jones is robustly defending all allegations, that the FCA's claim focuses on advertising rules and arranging investments, and that there is no allegation of fraud. Mr Mennie says he will share his full defence with investors when it is ready.
Refundee’s thoughts on the letter
It is correct that the FCA's public press release does focus on alleged unauthorised regulated activity, and it does not use the word fraud. However, the FCA's detailed court filings go further than alleging unauthorised regulated activity. As reported in our earlier update, they allege that new investors' money was used to pay returns to existing investors. The FCA clearly alleges it’s a Ponzi scheme.
We don’t agree that investors should wait and not take action until MHA reaches out. There are very strict timelines for many investors to achieve reimbursement. Therefore, we think the advice in the letter is the opposite to what investors should be doing. Investors need to take action now and can speak to Refundee about options.
Who is MHA?
MHA is a reputable UK accountancy and business advisory firm, and the UK member of the global Baker Tilly International network. The firm traces its roots back to 1869 and, according to its website, has around 1,900 staff and 24 offices across the UK. The insolvency practitioners that we believe are appointed are experienced in cases such as this.
What will MHA do?
The exact role depends on the type of appointment, which has not yet been publicly confirmed. Our assumption is that it will be an administration initially. In general terms, an insolvency practitioner in this position will:
- Take control of the SPVs' assets, books and records.
- Identify what properties and other assets the SPVs own, and what charges and debts sit against them.
- Write to investors and other creditors explaining the process and how to submit a claim.
- Sell or otherwise realise assets, then distribute money to creditors in the order set by law and by the security documents.
- Investigate how the companies were run and report on the conduct of directors to the Insolvency Service, where the process requires it.
- Take action against directors and associated entities or parties where appropriate. For example, this might include reversing transactions at undervalue or preference payments.
What does this mean for HJ Collection investors?
The appointment of an insolvency practitioner means the SPVs are no longer being run by Mr Mennie in the normal way. Control passes to MHA, whose duty is to creditors as a whole.
As above, one duty of the insolvency practitioner is to realise assets and take actions for the benefit of creditors as a whole.
Returns through insolvency are likely to be partial
In most insolvencies, creditors get back only part of what they are owed, if anything at all. and sometimes nothing. Several factors could reduce what HJ Collection investors receive:
- Other lenders may rank first. According to the FCA's filings, many properties were bought using bridging finance, and those lenders are likely to hold first charges. They would normally be repaid from the sale of a property before loan note holders.
- Assets may be worth less than expected. The FCA alleges that some properties were unfinished, in disrepair or showed no construction, and that some may be held in other entities or in Mr Mennie's personal name. If so, the security behind the loan notes may be weaker than investors were told.
- Costs come out first. The fees and costs of the insolvency process, and of any receiver or trustee, are usually paid before distributions to investors.
- Each SPV is separate. Your return will depend on the assets and debts of the specific SPV that issued your loan notes.
- Actions are expensive. If there are actions against directors or other parties, it can involve significant legal or funding costs. This reduces any distribution to creditors even when actions are successful.
These points are based on allegations and general insolvency principles. MHA's reports to creditors should give a clearer picture of each SPV's assets and liabilities.
It may take a long time
Insolvency processes involving property can take months or years, particularly where assets need to be sold or legal issues need to be resolved. Investors should not expect a quick outcome.
Bank reimbursement claims are not affected
The insolvency process does not stop you pursuing a claim against your bank. The two routes can run side by side, and information produced by the insolvency practitioner may even support a bank claim.
However, bank claims have their own deadlines, so waiting for the insolvency to finish is not a safe option. While you should engage fully with the insolvency process, you should not delay other action while it is ongoing.
Refundee has already submitted our clients' cases to banks and the Financial Ombudsman Service and we are pursuing further claims for affected investors
How can HJ Collection investors get their money back?
There is no single answer, and the right route depends on how much you invested, how you paid and when. The main options are summarised below. For more detail, read our guide to investment scams: your options for recovering lost money.
Beware of false promises and throwing good money after bad.
Often legal action against directors or other parties is marketed to investors in such situations as an option. This is attractive as it is more understood by normal investors than bank reimbursement cases. However, it’s often thrown out there as a marketing tool rather than a realistic option by law firms. In reality, it’s normal that these firms will pursue bank reimbursement claims anyway, which may not be their area of expertise.
When legal action is genuinely a consideration by law firms, it can be a useful option if bank reimbursement cases are not viable. However, while legal actions are very good at lining the pockets of lawyers, they are long winded and costs can escalate. This means that even where investors do win, reimbursement is usually only partial. Even worse, the losing party might not be able to pay you or, you could lose and end up even worse off.
Our view is that legal options should only be explored if you are not eligible for bank reimbursement claims. The insolvency firm will also typically consider legal options itself on behalf of the estate without creditors themself needing to foot the bill, and they work with panels of law firms who advise them on these options.
Claim through your bank and the Financial Ombudsman Service - the best option for most investors
For most HJ Collection investors who paid from a UK bank account, this is likely to be the most practical route. This is because:
- Banks have an obligation to reimburse in certain circumstances
Banks have obligations under the Contingent Reimbursement Model (CRM Code) and, for payments made on or after 7 October 2024, the Payment Systems Regulator's Mandatory Reimbursement rules. Reimbursement regulations is what Refundee specialises in; it’s all we do.
Banks often reject claims involving investment schemes by calling them a "civil dispute". If that happens, you can take your complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which can award up to £455,000 for complaints about events after 1 April 2019.
- There is no up front costs and you only pay if you get your money back and use a representative
The process is free to start so you are not throwing good money after bad. The worst case scenario is that you do not win and the only thing you’ve wasted is time. If you use Refundee, we work on a no win, no fee basis. Our fee is 15% + VAT of any money recovered, capped at £10,000 + VAT, and is only payable when the money lands back in your bank account.
- This is a regulatory process not a legal process
This is a regulatory process and so regulatory experts like Refundee are best placed to help via the Financial Ombudsman Service. The Financial Ombudsman Service is designed to be able to be used by lay people and you can make the claim yourself for free, or use Refundee.
- There is a proven track record of this working
According to the FCA’s court filings, the regulator alleges that money from newer loan note investors was used to repay earlier investors. The FCA alleges that Hunter Jones operated a Ponzi scheme. These are allegations. The court has not ruled on them, and Osborne Baldwin Limited (trading as Hunter Jones) and Mr Mennie deny them and say they will defend the case.
Refundee has recovered over £150m for investors across a range of investment-related cases, with more than half coming from cases we have won involving Ponzi schemes. We specialise in group actions involving investment schemes, including Ponzi schemes, and you can see examples of cases we’ve won on our group actions page.
Watch the deadline. For payments made on or after 7 October 2024, you need to report the claim to your bank within 13 months of your last payment. Investors who paid into HJ Collection 5 or HJ Collection 6 in late 2025 may be close to that cut-off now. Read more about the 13-month rule.
How Refundee can help HJ Collection investors
Refundee is running a group action of bank reimbursement claims for HJ Collection investors. We are progressing our cases as we believe there is enough evidence for investors to argue they are entitled to reimbursement and while history shows banks will fight it, we believe that there is a reasonable prospect of success.
We have been following HJ Collection and Hunter Jones closely for over a year, and have already recovered money. One investor had put money into a loan note arranged by Hunter Jones. In July 2023, we took their complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service and secured a full refund of £11,298.91, including interest and compensation. So we already have a proven track record.
More recently, where Hunter Jones loan notes repayments were delayed or refused, we have chased repayment for investors free of charge by issuing statutory demands. In one case, an investor recovered their full £50,000.
The insolvency appointment does not change our approach. Bank claims and the insolvency process can run side by side, and can be complimentary. We can help advise people how best they should approach this.
What to know before you contact us:
- Your initial eligibility assessment is free, and we will tell you honestly whether we think you have a claim.
- We work on a no win, no fee basis. Our fee is 15% + VAT of any money recovered, capped at £10,000 + VAT, and is only payable if we recover money for you. See our claim fees.
- We can currently only help investors who sent money from a UK bank account.
- You do not have to use a claims company. You can complain to your bank and the Ombudsman yourself for free, and our claim yourself guide explains how.
- Refundee is authorised and regulated by the FCA (FRN 937096). The HJ Collection letter rightly warns investors to be careful about unsolicited contact. We encourage you to check our details on the FCA register before speaking to us or any other firm.
If you invested in any HJ Collection SPV and want to find out whether you may be able to claim, start your free eligibility assessment.
Frequently asked questions
The 17 November 2026 letter confirms that MHA has been appointed by the Security Trustee as insolvency practitioner over the HJ Collection SPVs. Our understanding is that initially it will be an administration.
MHA is a reputable UK accountancy and advisory firm and the UK member of Baker Tilly International. It has a Restructuring and Recovery team of licensed insolvency practitioners who handle administrations, receiverships and liquidations.
It is possible you will get some money back, but investors should expect a partial return at best. Secured lenders, insolvency costs and the value of each SPV's properties will all affect what is left for loan note holders.
Yes, you need to report this to your bank as soon as possible or get Refundee to do this for you. For payments on or after 7 October 2024, the time limit is 13 months from your last payment. Even if you missed that date you should report it to your bank or reach out to Refundee and we can provide support.
Yes. What matters is that you made the payment from your own UK bank account to a UK bank account. How you were introduced to the investment does not usually prevent a claim.
No court has made that finding. The FCA alleges in its High Court claim that Hunter Jones carried out regulated activity without authorisation, and its filings allege that new investor money was used to repay earlier investors. The FCA also alleged that it was a Ponzi scheme. Hunter Jones and Mr Mennie deny the allegations and say they will defend the case.
The FCA's case against Osborne Baldwin Limited and Mr Mennie is separate and continues. The insolvency of the SPVs may affect how much money is available to return to investors, but it does not end the proceedings.
Only deal with contacts you can verify. Check that any firm offering help is on the FCA register, never share bank details with an unexpected caller, and be wary of anyone asking for upfront fees to recover your money.
Legal action against the companies or directors involved is often expensive, slow and uncertain, and can mean putting more money at risk. Before signing up for any legal action, ask exactly what claim will be brought, against whom, and what it will cost you if it fails. For eligible investors, we believe bank reimbursement claims are usually the better option because there are no upfront costs and the process is designed for consumers.
The letter on 17th November stated that Reece Mennie asked Bluewater Capital to appoint an administrator. However, Bluewater Capital does not need the instructions of Reece Mennie under their terms and could have initiated the proceedings regardless.
According to the security trust deeds sent to Refundee, Blue Water's role is to hold the security on behalf of investors, not to check it. In the HJ Collection 4 and 5 deeds we've reviewed, it is not required to check that the company owned the assets and its duties are "solely mechanical and administrative". This means the value of the security depends on the assets each SPV actually holds. If the SPVs do not hold assets, something that will be reviewed during the administration, then unfortunately the security may hold little value for investors. If you're unsure where you stand, get in touch and we can review your documents.



